Joey Chestnut vs. Inflation: A Glizzy Gauge of the American Economy
A Hot Dog Index More Accurate than the Fed's CPI Numbers...
Every Fourth of July, America celebrates its independence—and one man’s dominance over digestion. That man is Joey Chestnut.
For nearly two decades, Chestnut has reigned supreme at Coney Island’s Nathan’s Famous Hot Dog Eating Contest, turning a grotesque spectacle into a national ritual. But zoom out from the ketchup-smeared chaos, and you’ll find something unexpected:
Joey Chestnut’s performance might just be one of the most bizarrely consistent indicators of American inflation.
The Chestnut Index: A Brief History of Gluttony
Let’s start with the numbers:
At the start of Joey Chestnut’s career in 2007, a single hot dog was worth just $0.98 cents.
Hot dog price increase since 2007: +89.8%
Champion glizzy intake growth (2007 vs. peak): +15.2%
2024 upset: Chestnut did not compete due to a sponsorship dispute.
2024 champion: Bertoletti won with 58 dogs—down from Joey’s peak of 76 total dogs
Stomach vs. Inflation: Who Wins?
What started as a light-hearted sport now reveals a serious economic lesson.
While Joey’s glizzy count has hovered in the 60s and 70s, the cost of each dog has nearly doubled since 2007. That’s a bigger gain than Joey’s stomach ever achieved—and it mirrors the broader cost-of-living struggles hitting Americans across the board.
Hot dog prices reflect a lot of underlying factors:
Commodity costs (meat, wheat, fuel)
Labor and packaging
Supply chain volatility
Food inflation during COVID and beyond
The Chestnut Index becomes a weirdly effective symbol for what we’ve all felt: more cost, same consumption—or less (shrinkflation).
The Real American Hero: The $1.50 Glizzy That Defied the Fed
While Nathan’s hot dogs have succumbed to inflation, one combo has stayed strong:
Costco’s legendary $1.50 hot dog and soda.
Unchanged since 1985, this price has survived wars, recessions, pandemics, and Powell rate hikes. Former CEO Jim Sinegal famously warned:
“If you raise the effing hot dog, I will kill you.”
Adjusted for inflation, that combo should now cost about $4.40. But Costco won’t budge—and in doing so, they’ve become America’s economic folk hero.
If Joey had eaten Costco hot dogs during his 2021 record, it would’ve cost just $114, soda included.
Fourth of July 2025 Outlook: The Appetite Slows
After a year in exile, Joey Chestnut is set to return to Coney Island, to reclaim his title and give America one more patriotic spectacle.
But this year’s contest carries a different energy. With hot dog prices projected to hit $1.92 by year’s end, inflation still biting, and consumer appetite shrinking, Chestnut’s return feels less like a triumphant comeback… and more like a last decadent hurrah.
It’s hard not to draw comparisons to the twilight of the Roman Empire—when lavish festivals and gladiator games offered the illusion of vitality as the system quietly unraveled beneath.
One final feast. One more glorious spectacle. Before the barbarians arrive—or the Fed pivots.
As the nation gathers to cheer on Chestnut devouring 60+ hot dogs in 10 minutes, it may not just be about food, or records, or tradition.
It might be about clinging to that fleeting, greasy moment of excess before reality sets in.
Final Thoughts from the Rabbit Hole
The total percentage change in the U.S. CPI from December 2007 to December 2024 was approximately 51.1%. The Chestnut Index’s reported inflation from 2007 to 2024 was approximately 89.8%. In a strange way, Joey Chestnut’s hot dog count has become an oddball barometer for American economic health. The Chestnut Index is the new CPI, less fraudulent and more accurately representative of true inflation numbers.
As the price per dog inflates and Joey’s totals level off, it’s hard not to see the metaphor:
The American stomach—like the American wallet—can only stretch so far.
The Empire is being devoured by inflation.
Happy Fourth of July,
-Tyler
PS. Like & Share this article with somebody who's “Got that Dog in em.”